Showing posts with label foresight. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foresight. Show all posts

The Many Definitions Of "Sustainability"

I've been skeptical of terms as they come and go. (earlier post) Sustainability, again, is one of them. Yup, cultural definitions evolve and morph. But when the tag for the future dynamic of Earth jumps all over the map, we need to take stock of what exactly is at stake. 

The following definitions were compiled and distributed recently by a conference session here in Madison. They represent some current versions of sustainability. I'm taking the liberty to comment. Others?

  • Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the needs of future generations to meet their own needs.
Brundtland Report (World Commission on Environment & Development)
Is sustainable development an oxymoron?

  • Sustainable design is the set of perceptual and analytic abilities, ecological         wisdom, and practical wherewithal essential to making things that fit in a world of microbes, plants, animals, and entropy. In other words, (sustainability) is the careful meshing of human purposes with the larger patterns and flows of the natural world, and careful study of those patterns and flows to inform human purposes.
David Orr, Ecological Literacy 
Philosophically sound if humans follow suit with patterns and flows. 

  • Sustainability is the ability to achieve continuing economic prosperity while protecting the natural systems of the planet and providing a high quality of life for its people. Achieving sustainable solutions calls for stewardship, with everyone taking responsibility for solving the problems of today and tomorrow-individuals, communities, businesses and governments are all stewards of the environment.
 Environmental Protection Agency
This government agency has two sides to its mouth: economic prosperity vs. stewardship.  Paradox.

  • Sustainability is asking ourselves today: How much do we really need? Then, not taking more from the earth than that.
Alliance for Global Sustainability Principle Investors
Huh…?

  • A transition to sustainability involves moving from linear to cyclical processes and technologies. The only processes we can rely on indefinitely are cyclical; all linear processes must eventually come to an end. 
Dr. Karl Henrik-Robert, MD, founder of The Natural Step, Sweden
True.


  • Sustainability is the capacity to endure. In ecology the word describes how biological systems remain diverse and productive over time. Long-lived and healthy wetlands and forests are examples of sustainable biological systems. For humans, sustainability is the potential for long-term maintenance of wellbeing, which has environmental, economic, and social dimensions.
Wikipedia (Jan 2011)
The first sentence is true, which is why resilience may be a better overall concept than sustainability.


  • Sustainability occurs when human activity does not adversely affect the quality of the environment and resource base available for future generations of living things on the planet.
Alliance for Global Sustainability Principle Investors
Many resource bases have already been altered beyond future availability.


  • Sustainability is equity over time.  As a value, it refers to giving equal weight in your decisions to the future as well as the present. You might think of it as extending the Golden Rule through time, so that you do unto future generations (as well as to your present fellow beings) as you would have them do unto you.
Robert Gilman, Director Context Institute
Yes.  ["Why should I do anything for future generations. They haven't done anything for me." Groucho Marx]


  • Leave the world better than you found it, take no more than you need, try not to harm life or the environment, make amends if you do.
Paul Hawken
True, but already unattainable. 

  • A thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise.
Aldo Leopold, A Land Ethic, from Sand County Almanac
Simple and wise…

  • Clean air, clean water, safety in city parks, low-income housing, education, child care, welfare, medical care, unemployment (insurance), transportation, recreation/cultural centers, open space, wetlands... 
Hazel Wolf, Seattle Audubon Society
Finally getting to the social justice?




What is the Essence of Preparation for Children?

What is the essence of preparation for adulthood, coupled with the preparation for a changing society? I mean, what is the resilience factor that kids need to acquire to be productive and confident in 2020? It's an ethics question as well as an imperative practical standard for education. 


Dianne Monroe
Dianne Monroe has extensive experience with children who are facing struggles in life on a family level. She wonders how this type of life challenge can be applied to the resilience needed by our current crop of kids who will face struggles in life on a societal level. 


This is the core of where we need to be focused.


Carolyn Baker is a psychotherapist and counselor dedicated to preparing and assisting folks for our future. Dianne Monroe wrote the following on Carolyn's blog.

Read the original "To Touch a Changing Sky: Raising Children in Changing Times", or the transcript here.

We have received a tremendous gift – to be alive at the edge of these changing times. It’s not an easy gift, if we look open-eyed into possible futures. Yet within this gift lies the tremendous opportunity (and yes, responsibility) of crafting tools to place in the hands of those who come after, to enable them to shape the world in which they live through their own vision.

If you have children in your lives – as parents, grandparents, educators or in any other way – there’s a particular magnitude to this. You have no doubt asked yourself what you can do to enable them to navigate the turbulent times ahead, to build meaningful lives in the midst of crisis and decline, to greet the future with creativity, resilience and joy.

“How can we nurture and raise children so they can grow into adults who are able to survive, thrive and contribute to new ways of being with the Earth and each other? ” This is how I pose this question to myself as I look into the hopeful eyes of the children whose lives I have the opportunity to touch through my work. It is perhaps this sense of contributing to new ways of being with the Earth and each other that will make it possible for the youth of today to survive and thrive in a challenging and rapidly changing world.

Carolyn Baker writes in Navigating the Coming Chaos about the upcoming collapse (Great Turning, Great Unraveling, Transition, or by any other name) as “humanity’s next rite of passage, our imminent initiation into adulthood as a species.” In Sacred Demise, she writes of an “odyssey” that “is about the transformation of human consciousness and the emergence of a new paradigm as a result of discovering our purpose in the collapse process and thereby coming home to our ultimate place in the universe.”

Bill Plotkin, in Nature and the Human Soul, writes that, “we must mature into people who are, first and foremost, citizens of Earth and residents of the universe, and our identity and core values must be recast accordingly. This kind of maturation entails a quantum leap beyond the stage of development in which the majority of people live today. And yet we must begin now to engender the future human.”

So how do we prepare our children to take their place in this multi-generational species initiation, to find their way to joyful, meaningful lives in the midst of crisis and difficulties we can only imagine? How can we cultivate the growth of interior structures that can enable the youth of today, the adults of tomorrow, to make their contribution to a transformation perhaps as huge as re-visioning what it means to be human?

This wide-vision of humanity’s future, not turning away from the difficulties and hardships, yet recognizing the potentials that grow within this crisis, has everything to do with an approach I have developed through my work with youth, that I now share with you.

Tools for Shaping Their Future

For over 20 years, part of my work has been with children in difficult circumstances (children in Child Protective Services care, children who have experienced abuse, immigrant and refugee youth and others). Daily I asked myself what I could give them that would really last, that they could hold on to and use as they charted their uncertain futures.

As I considered the future of all children and the juncture we are headed into, I realized that the things I developed for children in difficult circumstances were exactly what all youth needed to find their own way through the difficult times people and our planet are facing, to help shape a new and different future.

 I saw that the ways I developed to build internal structures with children who life had dealt a difficult hand also builds those internal structures with all children facing challenging situations. This nurturing of interior structures is perhaps the most important gift we can offer youth today, to enable them to play their full role in these times of human initiation and transformation.

 My approach revolves around four qualities and strengths adults can cultivate with the children in their lives, and a wide variety of practices, activities and experiences that can nurture them. They can be brought into a broad range of situations, are adaptable for youth of any age, and can be shaped to fit differing interests and inclinations.

These four qualities and strengths are:

Inner Self

For youth to survive, thrive and make their contribution to this time of transformation, it is essential that they that they learn to know, value, and trust their inner voice, that they become deeply rooted in a sense of self. Beyond this, it is crucial for children (and adults) to understand that they have gifts to bring to this world, something valuable to offer to the times in which they live. I tell children that this is true even if they do not yet know what it is because they are still growing, and it is yet to be discovered – and that discovery can be as joyful as unwrapping a birthday present. This sense of purpose, the soil from which their life’s meaning will take root and flower, is one of the most valuable things we can offer those who are youth today.

Creativity and Imagination

“A healthy imagination is essential to growing up, becoming fully human, encountering our souls, and offering our unique and necessary gifts to the world,” writes Bill Plotkin in Nature and the Human Soul.

Creativity and Imagination are an integral part of what it means to be human, a vital resource we each carry within. By nurturing these qualities with the children in our lives we offer them ways of knowing and growing their inner selves, finding personal meaning and enjoyment in life, and as a way of seeking solutions to, or ways of being with, life’s challenges and difficulties. Through cultivating creativity and imagination, we offer children resources for growing into and through the coming times, and for making their contribution to re-visioning humanity’s future.

Connection with Nature

We are part of the natural world and evolved within its embrace. This understanding is perhaps as ancient as humanity itself. Giving children the gift of knowing nature as their home, feeling themselves as part of the web of life is an invaluable life resource for exploring their inner self and developing their ability to act in this world and on its behalf.

It is perhaps our culture’s break with nature, the viewing of our planet as nothing more than a collection of things to be exploited and discarded, that has brought us to this time of crisis. And perhaps more than anything else, this time of turmoil and transformation calls for a rediscovery of humanity’s place within the earth community. This re-visioning of our relationship with life on earth, rooted in indigenous wisdom and shaped for contemporary times, is perhaps the cornerstone of the human initiation and evolution being called for today.

For youth to discover their place within the natural world, to grow their connection with it, has everything to do with their ability to remain grounded in turbulent times, everything to do with them being able to grow their vision and play their part in this upcoming transition.

Joy, Gratitude, Wonder

We live in a magnificent world. Children express joy and wonder naturally and beautifully. It can be a delightful experience for adults to help children cultivate and deepen this natural way of being with the world. Knowing what brings you joy strengthens sense of self and connection with the world. The ability to find joy, gratitude and wonder in difficult circumstances, in places where it may not be obvious or easy to see can make a big difference in how people experience and respond to times of crisis and change. This capacity is a vital part of finding and making meaning in life, in the fundamental redefining of “a good life” that our times are calling for.

A Note About Resilience

It almost goes without saying that children (and adults) need resilience to meet the future. Resilience is a complex interweaving of many qualities. Core resilience is rooted in two things, the ability to be grounded in self and the ability to respond creatively and flexibly to change. This is fundamentally the same as the qualities of Inner Self, Creativity, and Imagination. By nurturing these qualities you are actually growing resilience.

Knowing one’s place as part of the natural world, feeling this connection, brings a groundedness and flexibility in times of challenge and change. The capacity for joy, gratitude and wonder offers a source connection and replenishment, especially valuable in difficult times. Perhaps the most powerful component of resilience is the deeply rooted knowing that you have something valuable to bring and a part to play in the unfolding drama of these times, an opportunity to touch and shape the unfolding of the future, and something important to pass on to those who come after.

Through Their Own Vision

There are countless activities, practices and experiences that can nurture these qualities and strengths. Many I have developed during my years of working with youth. Many have been developed by others. Many more will undoubtedly be developed in the future. There may be ways you are already nurturing some, or all, of these qualities and strengths with the children in your lives.

Here are a pair of simple yet powerful practices you can easily share with the children in your lives. Notice how they reinforce each other, and how they each nurture several of these four qualities and strengths.

Wandering

Wandering is spending unstructured time in nature, with no plan or agenda, following what draws one’s attention. This common childhood experience not so long ago has become a rarity in today’s urban and suburban environments.

Wandering offers children the gift of falling in love with the world. It builds a connection with nature, opening children (and adults) to feeling themselves as part of the web of life and knowing nature as their home. It also develops the relationship between nature and inner self, cultivates intuition and deepens trust in one’s inner voice.

Adults can create opportunities for children to wander in nature. We can support them in deepening their experience by asking them questions about their adventures and the things they are drawn to. For example: Tell me about what makes that rock (or flower or lizard or weed) special to you? How do you think it feels to be a bird (or the wind, or a caterpillar)? If the tree could talk with the stream what do you think they would say? Children can be encouraged to keep a journal where they write or draw about their experiences, their feelings and responses to the things they encounter.

Freeplay and Free Art – Imagination Running Wild

Just as adults can make space for and encourage external wandering, it is vital that we open space for and encourage exploring internal landscapes. Free play and daydreaming are natural childhood activities that, like wandering, are increasingly rare in today’s overscheduled lives. They foster the development of interior structures and grow the capacity for vision.

Free art is the natural companion to free play. This innate flowing of experiences, feelings, imagination through any art form is very different from “how to” art lessons. Adults can encourage youth to draw, paint, sculpt (with clay, mud or any other substance) sing, dance, write, tell a story about their imaginary experiences. We can ask to be invited into children’s imaginary world and pose questions to extend and deepen their experiences, taking care not to direct or impose. We can also ask questions that encourage the use of imagination. For example: How many things could this stick be? (Hints: a magic wand, an antenna, an insect, Pinocchio’s nose.) Children can be encouraged to use journals or folders to gather their free art, and to return to these creations for further exploration and elaboration.

Through free play, daydreaming and free art, children explore and expand their understanding of their inner selves and discover their unique relationship with the world around them. These activities offer a safe structure for them to explore their emotions, including their fears, and to seek solutions for imaginary-world problems that can carry over into “real world” problem-solving skills. Most importantly, they cultivate the capacity for vision – that necessary quality for discovering and sharing one’s gifts, for finding their place and making their contributions to the future world in which they will live.

Writing Our Horizon

We are entering, perhaps have already entered, a new paradigm, an unknown that has not existed on this scale since perhaps the dawn of what we call civilization. And with this, a possibly unprecedented opportunity to reach out and touch the future. We can see the outline dimly on the horizon, yet the flow of history always evolves a bit differently from what anyone envisioned.

We live at a conjuncture when seemingly small actions can reverberate through time, like widening circles around a pebble tossed into a still pond. The story of this time has not yet been written. Daily, in ways large and small, we are writing the opening lines of that story. Perhaps our most important work will be the developing and passing on of writing tools for these times. The tools, gifts, resources we offer the next generation, the children in our lives today, will ripple outward throughout the length of this journey.

~ ~ ~
Readin', writin' & 'rithmetic have become such an overwhelming staple of daily classwork, and rightly so.  BUT, imbedded within these disciplines (along with their poor cousins science and social studies) is the task of slowly strengthening in children an enthusiastic confidence for openness and problem solving.


Do You Scratch and Claw to Stay Tuned to the World?

Busy lives. The world turns. Staying up to date on a daily basis is a chore, even with the newly anointed Scott Pelley on CBS. A full dose of Wolf still takes some screen time.


Are we really, though, getting the stories that matter to the future of 4th graders?? 


We are sort of on the cusp of seeing mainstream media reporting on uncomfortable issues of our future - beyond the economy. (Choose an economy; how about Greece...) In general, the themes of water, peak oil, climate change, cultural conflicts (read wars) and the needs of citizens in coming decades are neglected miserably.

Many blogsites compile pertinent daily articles and send them out as a bundle to subscribers. (Sometimes there is a small subscription fee.) Articles are culled from many sources and cover everything from breaking news to opinion. 


Such as:
Speaking Truth to Power Daily News Digest from Carolyn Baker
Common Dreams
Energy Bulletin


Here are some examples of articles brought to light on subscription bundles in only the past two weeks or so (of many more!). Take a glance at the variety of content, which is generally neglected in reports from other media. I have highlighted key words. Scan the variety of articles. Get a feel for how this may impact your own perceptions.


6/3/11 Wangari Maathai: Spiritual Environmentalism—Healing Ourselves by Replenishing the Earth
6/13/11 Oil company's lawsuit against Greenpeace backfires
6/2/11 Why Our Most Urgent Climate Struggles May Be Winnable by Bill McKibben
6/1/11 Population Footprints: Rights and Responsibilities — Behind the Numbers: The PRB blog on population, health, and the environment
6/1/11 Chris Hedges: The Sky Really Is Falling - Chris Hedges' Columns - Truthdig
6/15/11 Lawn Care Goes to the Sheep in a Pennsylvania School District - Planet Green
5/29/11 The Reality of Global Climate Change is Upon Us - Newsweek
6/3/11 Shortages of Fresh Water Seen as Emerging Threat - ABC News
6/13/11 USGS: Global Warming Drives Rockies Snowpack Loss Unrivaled in 800 Years, Threatens Western Water Supply
6/16/11 Summer Reading Suggestions | Center for Ecoliteracy
6/14/11 The Truth About The Economy In 2 Minutes | MoveOn.Org
6/16/11 Small farms may be better for food security and biodiversity | Science Matters | David Suzuki Foundation
5/2/11 In U.S., Optimism About Future for Youth Reaches All-Time Low
6/17/11 Humane Connection: 7 Resources for Finding Out About the Secret Lives of Your Stuff
6/14/11 Children Pay Ultimate Price of Iraq's Poisonous Wartime Legacy | Common Dreams
6/5/11 Josh Golin: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Commerce... and Other Scholastic Satires
6/1/11 The New Geopolitics of Food - By Lester R. Brown | Foreign Policy
6/10/11 Humanitarian crisis as world's largest refugee camp declared full | World news | guardian.co.uk
6/1/11 An End to Growth: The Environment’s Impact on our Economic Decline | Oil Price.com
2/16/11 Two seminal Nature papers join growing body of evidence that human emissions fuel extreme weather, flooding that harm humans and the environment | ThinkProgress
6/7/11 BBC News - Tropical forests 'better managed'
6/17/11 Will Alternative Energy Save Us From Peak Oil | Oil Price.com
6/13/11 Oil-giant Venezuela tries to limit energy use - Yahoo! News
6/3/11 Video: 15 Years of Saying YES!
5/26/11 The geology of the planet: Welcome to the Anthropocene | The Economist
6/15/11 Ten Charts That Embody Everything That's Wrong With The U.S. Economy
6/12/11 Field Notes from the Future- Children and Nature.Org
6/1/11 The Oil Drum | Oil prices and recession
6/7/11 Yemen Facing Humanitarian Catastrophe: UNICEF | Common Dreams
6/1/11 In The World After Abundance | Energy Bulletin
6/15/11 Sewing and Clothing Repair | Preparedness Advice Blog
6/16/11 Nebraska Nuclear Reactor Flooded

We do sifting and winnowing in class each day. I hope this creates resources for sifting the challenges of resilience to come.



Got To Have Happiness! :-)



What is Gross National Happiness??
“An interviewer asked why I put so much store in young people. Because young people don’t know what’s impossible. They are less burdened by the past so will try something new without bothering to ask if it has been tried before. That is always how big changes occur. When people set out to imagine a different future, there are no authorities."
William Greider

Youth will lead the way into a different future. But is there a spirit or outlook that can drive this leadership? Well-being? 


(love this graph's title)

We have something called the Gross National Product, which measures the full amount of economic productivity by a nation in terms of dollars. Then there's the Gross Domestic Product, which measures such activities only within a country’s borders. Since 1992, the US and most countries have used Gross Domestic Product. 


The GDP tends to be the dominant measure for the health of a nation. If this is the case, exactly which sector of health are we talking about?


“Gross National Product does not allow for the health of our children, the quality of their education, or the joy of their play. It does not include the beauty of our poetry or the strength of our marriages, the intelligence of our public debate or the integrity of our public officials. It measures neither our wit nor our courage, neither our wisdom nor our learning, neither our compassion nor our devotion to our country; it measures everything, in short, except that which makes life worthwhile.”        
 Robert F. Kennedy



For the past 40 years or so, a corollary view to GDP has been Gross National Happiness. Begun in the early 1970‘s in the Himalayan nation of Bhutan, the concept of Gross National Happiness is spreading today, notably in Brazil, Italy, Canada and the USA.

Measuring GDH is somewhat dicey but it does provide a framework for shifting away from our reliance on economic development and toward a focus on human contentment. GDH is a check and balance indicator of how healthy and happy a society is within this economic growth trance we've nurtured. 


Certainly, one form of a wake-up call to Gross National Happiness came from Egypt these past weeks. Citizens met their breaking point with frustrations involving jobs, food availability, an overpopulated region and restricted liberties. Lack of resources for sustaining daily life would frustrate anyone. Was there too much reliance on a GDP? Did this force GNH to take center stage?

Closer to home, Gross National Happiness USA is spreading its wonderful messages from the East Coast. Movements such as Sustainable Seattle are leading the way on the West Coast, where their Seattle Area Happiness Initiative includes a survey of The Nine Dimensions of Happiness. This list comes from GNH-USA, where you'll find more detailed explanations. 

How do these dimensions of happiness fit for you?

1. psychological well-being;
2. physical health;
3. time or work-life balance;
4. social connection and   community vitality;
5. education;
6. access to arts, culture and recreation;
7. environmental quality and access to nature;
8. good governance;
9 material well-being.

Is this a list pertinent to all global cultures? Just a thought…

"There's no present like the time." (Hard to say, isn't it?) 



Take Back Your Time, another US/Canadian venture incorporating GDH, seeks to encourage community interactions by refocusing daily "time famines" and overwork issues.


Collectively, then, GDH movements enable us to begin down the road of resiliency: a contentment with eyes wide open.



Seventh Generation Foresights


The Seventh Generation concept was ingrained in the people of North America even as the takeover by Europeans began 500+ years ago. This cultural ingredient was and is a moral promise to Mother Earth and to descendants of the human communities.

Before the traditional Iroquois convened their consul meetings, 
they invoked this declaration:

“In our every deliberation we must consider 
the impact of our decisions on the next seven generations.”

The rights of future generations never became an issue of policy 

because it was, instead, the very context of policy. 
Conservation was, thus, the very foundation upon which 
their culture was built. The medium was the message.
Jim Nollman

It is further explained how, over time, we Westerners have become simply observers of nature instead of nurturers in a communion with nature. The lack of the true bond to the networks of the planet, which include homo sapien, blurs our view of a future. 

~ ~ ~ ~

For a time I was personally totally engrossed with genealogy. Following my family back into time was an intriguing journey in history and ancestral lineage. One of the tools I used to organize my searches was a large five generation chart for each side of the family. The lines and spaces for each generation branch into thicker and thicker blocks. Ancestral names, dates of births and deaths are recorded as research continues. Additional details for each family are recorded on separate sheets, but this one chart gives one a quick look at the extent of the lineage. It is the table of contents for the family tree.

A descendent chart, on the other hand, just doesn't work. It's hard to envision. We don't know the dates and names of folks to come. They are, seemingly, unimportant, past those grandkids and maybe great grandkids already part of the family. We may speculate about our own unborn grandchildren but, realistically, they don't get placed onto a chart. We don't think a whole lot about ongoing generations. I know we don't give much thought to descendents in relation to their own contemporary quality of life, or the state of their society. 


Shouldn't we...?


~ ~ ~ ~ ~
A generation is currently considered to be a period of about 30 years. Seven generations takes us out quite distance on the timeline, but three generations may be easier to grasp. If you are now 30, you might become a grandparent when you are 60. That's in 2040. 


(Yup, I'm going to bring it up...) 


In that era, climate disruptions will be in fuller swing and fossil fuels for electricity and heating and transportation will be restricted. I am hopeful that our society will have made major transitions to live with less and will have retooled daily life; the life of our descendents.


~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
It's the hindsight/foresight thing. Instead of 20:20 hindsight, we need 2020 foresight...just for starters. How do we educate for stuff like this?



Just like the human heartbeat, the seventh generation is 
singing its quiet song just about everywhere these days. 
Teach yourself how to listen. Teach a friend. An enemy.